Men's Vintage & Thrift Stores in Brooklyn: Complete Guide

Men's vintage thrift shopping in Brooklyn is quietly excellent. While a lot of the borough's secondhand scene caters broadly to all genders, there are a handful of stores where the men's sections are genuinely outstanding — deep on denim, strong on outerwear, and reliably stocked with the workwear, streetwear, and heritage pieces that are hard to find in a mainstream retail environment. This guide covers the best destinations for men's vintage and thrift in Brooklyn, organized by what each shop does best.

**Best Overall Men's Selection: Urban Jungle, Bushwick**

“Urban Jungle at 118 Knickerbocker Ave in Bushwick has built one of the best men's vintage sections in Brooklyn through a”

Urban Jungle at 118 Knickerbocker Ave in Bushwick has built one of the best men's vintage sections in Brooklyn through a combination of volume, honest sourcing, and reasonable pricing. The men's floor is extensive — flannel shirts, workwear jackets, vintage denim, military surplus, band tees, and outerwear all get real dedicated space rather than being shoehorned into a corner. Prices run $8–$35 for most items, with standout pieces appropriately priced higher. The selection changes frequently enough that regulars make Urban Jungle a weekly stop. This is where you come for the hunt — organized but not boutique-precious, with enough volume that every visit turns up something new.

**Best Curated Men's Edit: Crossroads Trading, Williamsburg**

Crossroads Trading at 135 N 7th St in Williamsburg runs a buy-sell-trade model that naturally filters for quality, and the men's section reflects the high bar of what Williamsburg residents bring in to sell. Expect contemporary secondhand from brands like Patagonia, Carhartt, Norse Projects, and the occasional designer piece at prices that make sense — $20–$60 for outerwear, $15–$35 for shirts and pants. Crossroads is not a vintage shop in the traditional sense, but it's excellent for quality contemporary menswear at fair secondhand prices. The floor is organized and well-presented, which makes assessment quick.

**Best for Classic Vintage Menswear: 10 ft Single by Stella Dallas, Williamsburg**

10 ft Single by Stella Dallas at 285 N 6th St is primarily known as a women's vintage shop, but the men's section is worth your time if you're hunting for proper vintage — pre-1990 pieces with provenance, quality fabric, and honest construction. The shop's curation philosophy extends to the men's racks: expect deadstock Western shirts, well-preserved 1970s leisure wear, quality 1960s sport coats, and the occasional rare find that a boutique in the East Village would price three times higher. Inventory is smaller than the women's section but meaningfully curated.

**Best for Workwear and Americana: Domsey Express, Williamsburg**

Domsey Express at 431 Broadway is the heavyweight answer for men's workwear, denim, and Americana vintage. The warehouse-scale operation receives enormous donation volumes and the men's section — particularly outerwear, denim, and flannel — is consistently deep. Domsey sells by the pound in some sections, which means the pricing is genuinely some of the lowest in Brooklyn for men's clothing. A vintage Carhartt chore coat at a boutique in Williamsburg might run $120; at Domsey you might find a comparable piece for $8–$15. The experience requires patience and a willingness to dig, but men's vintage buyers who know workwear will find Domsey worth every minute.

**Best for Men's Streetwear and Sneakers: Buffalo Exchange, Williamsburg**

Buffalo Exchange at 504 Driggs Ave has a men's section that skews toward contemporary streetwear — recent-era Nike, Supreme, vintage sports jerseys, and the kind of pieces that cycle quickly through the resale market. This is a better option for men who shop the current streetwear/vintage-adjacent aesthetic than for collectors hunting heritage workwear or true vintage. Prices are fair and clearly marked, the turnover is fast, and the buy-sell-trade model means you can offset your spending by trading in pieces from your own closet.

**Best Neighborhood for Men's Vintage Shopping: Williamsburg to Bushwick Loop**

The single best men's thrift day in Brooklyn runs a loose loop from Williamsburg's Grand Street corridor up to the Bedford Ave cluster, then east into Bushwick. Start at Domsey Express on Broadway for the bulk finds, work north to Grand Street Local and L Train Vintage for mid-range volume, hit 10 ft Single and Crossroads on the north end of Bedford Ave, then take the L east to Morgan Ave and finish at Urban Jungle and Beacon's Closet in Bushwick. The whole circuit is doable in a long afternoon, and you'll cover the full spectrum from warehouse-budget to curated-boutique in a single run.

**Best Budget Men's Option: L Train Vintage (Multiple Locations)**

L Train Vintage is the most accessible option for budget-conscious men's shoppers, with Brooklyn locations in Williamsburg (629 Grand St), East Williamsburg (106 Thames St), Bed-Stuy (392 Myrtle Ave), Crown Heights (743 Nostrand Ave), and Sunset Park (4602 5th Ave). The men's sections at each location lean heavily on volume and fair pricing — most pieces in the $8–$25 range — with an emphasis on casual vintage rather than collector finds. If you need to fill out a wardrobe quickly without spending much, L Train hits the right balance of selection and value. The Bed-Stuy location on Myrtle Ave tends to have a particularly strong men's workwear and streetwear mix.

**Best for Menswear in South Brooklyn: Beacon's Closet, Park Slope**

Beacon's Closet in Park Slope (92 5th Ave) pulls from one of Brooklyn's wealthiest donor neighborhoods, and the men's section reflects that: quality wool blazers, barely worn designer outerwear, and contemporary secondhand in excellent condition surface regularly. Prices are higher than at the budget shops but lower than at Williamsburg boutiques — $25–$65 for outerwear, $15–$35 for most clothing. This is the right option for men who want quality secondhand without the dig, presented in a clean and well-organized environment.

**What to Look For in Men's Brooklyn Thrift Shopping**

A few categories where Brooklyn thrift stores reliably over-deliver for men: denim, particularly Levi's 501s and 505s in vintage washes (look at inside waistband stamps to date them); outerwear, especially 1980s–90s nylon coaches jackets, flight jackets, and Carhartt work coats; flannel shirts in 100% cotton plaids (the synthetics feel immediately different); and vintage athletic wear — 80s–90s college sweatshirts, football jerseys, and track suits. These are the categories where Brooklyn thrift stores reliably deliver quality at a fraction of what the same pieces cost in vintage boutiques or on resale platforms.

Wear easy layers when you shop — many shops don't have fitting rooms, and being able to try a jacket over your current outfit is essential. Bring cash for smaller shops. And build extra time into your plan: the best men's vintage finds in Brooklyn don't announce themselves. They require a second look and a willingness to pull things off the rack that don't look promising at first glance.