Mondy's Thrifty

About Mondy's Thrifty

Mondy's Thrifty on Rogers Avenue is the kind of store that Flatbush residents have relied on for years without it ever making a Williamsburg thrift guide. That obscurity is precisely its appeal: this is a high-volume, community-first thrift operation where prices are set for the neighborhood and the inventory reflects the West Indian and Caribbean-American donor base that has made Rogers Avenue one of Brooklyn's most culturally distinct commercial corridors.

The selection covers the full range of everyday essentials — men's and women's clothing, children's wear, shoes, and accessories — with rotating stock that reflects what the surrounding community donates. Name-brand finds and quality pieces surface regularly, priced without the premium that curation-focused shops would apply. This is thrifting as it has always functioned in working-class Brooklyn: practical, affordable, and embedded in the neighborhood rather than marketed to it.

Pricing is among the lowest in the borough — most clothing falls in the $3–$8 range — and the open Monday through Saturday hours (9am–8pm) give it one of the wider scheduling windows of any thrift store in South Brooklyn. The 2 and 5 trains at Sterling Street are the closest subway access, connecting Mondy's to the wider Brooklyn transit network. For shoppers doing a South Brooklyn thrift circuit, it pairs naturally with Le Point Value Flatbush on nearby Clarkson Avenue.

What to Expect